MaplePitch Logo

Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers of All Time

Penalty kicks have always been a crucial part of football, demanding accuracy and calm under pressure. The Premier League has witnessed some remarkable players who excelled in this art. Leading the list is Alan Shearer with 56 penalty goals, followed closely by Yaya Touré, who boasts a flawless record. Other standout names include Matt Le Tissier and Harry Kane, while newer talents like Cole Palmer and Erling Haaland continue to make their mark.

Scoring from the spot requires more than just skill; it calls for nerve and precision. Many Premier League stars have etched their names into history by maintaining composure when it mattered most. Here’s a look at the top 10 penalty takers in the league’s history, highlighting their clubs, active years, and goal tallies.

Top 10 Premier League Penalty Scorers

  • Rank: 10 - Bukayo Saka, Arsenal, 2019–Present, Penalties Scored: 12
  • Rank: 9 - James Beattie, Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, Stoke City, 1998–2010, Penalties Scored: 16
  • Rank: 8 - Callum Wilson, Bournemouth, Newcastle United, 2014–Present, Penalties Scored: 16
  • Rank: 7 - Erling Haaland, Manchester City, 2022–Present, Penalties Scored: 20
  • Rank: 6 - Danny Murphy, Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, Fulham, 1997–2013, Penalties Scored: 18
  • Rank: 5 - Harry Kane, Tottenham Hotspur, 2012–2023, Penalties Scored: 33
  • Rank: 4 - Cole Palmer, Manchester City, Chelsea, 2021–Present, Penalties Scored: 18
  • Rank: 3 - Matt Le Tissier, Southampton, 1992–2002, Penalties Scored: 25
  • Rank: 2 - Yaya Touré, Manchester City, 2010–2018, Penalties Scored: 11
  • Rank: 1 - Alan Shearer, Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle United, 1992–2006, Penalties Scored: 56

Profiles of Premier League’s Best Penalty Takers

10. Bukayo Saka (Arsenal)

The young English winger learned resilience after missing a penalty in the UEFA Euro 2020 final. Since then, he has become a reliable finisher for Arsenal, boasting a 92% conversion rate with 12 successful penalties out of 13 attempts.

  • Appearances: 223
  • Goals: 59
  • Penalty Conversion: 92%

9. James Beattie

Beattie’s journey through several clubs made him a feared penalty taker, scoring 16 from 17 attempts. His only miss didn’t cost his team thanks to a win in that game.

  • Appearances: 270
  • Goals: 90
  • Penalty Conversion: 94%

8. Callum Wilson

Wilson has been consistent since his time at Bournemouth. Known for his calmness, he has scored 16 penalties with a 94% success rate.

  • Appearances: 267
  • Goals: 94
  • Penalty Conversion: 94%

7. Erling Haaland (Manchester City)

Haaland rarely misses, scoring 20 penalties in 23 attempts. Whether it’s a big game or not, his focus on scoring remains unshaken.

  • Appearances: 129
  • Goals: 109
  • Penalty Conversion: 87%

6. Danny Murphy

Only denied once by Joe Hart, Murphy was known for his clinical finishing in the 2000s. He converted 18 penalties in his career, maintaining a 95% success rate.

  • Appearances: 417
  • Goals: 66
  • Penalty Conversion: 95%

5. Harry Kane (Tottenham Hotspur)

Kane scored 33 penalties out of 37, an 89% conversion rate. Although slightly lower than others, his record still places him among the best.

  • Appearances: 320
  • Goals: 213
  • Penalty Conversion: 89%

4. Cole Palmer

Palmer had a near-perfect record with 18 goals from 19 penalties. His composure against tough opponents makes him stand out among young talents.

  • Appearances: 111
  • Goals: 46
  • Penalty Conversion: 95%

3. Matt Le Tissier

A legend at Southampton, Le Tissier scored 24 penalties out of 25 attempts. His only miss came in 1993, but his overall accuracy remains remarkable.

  • Appearances: 270
  • Goals: 101
  • Penalty Conversion: 96%

2. Yaya Touré

Touré is the only player with a 100% penalty record in the Premier League, scoring all 11 penalties he took for Manchester City.

  • Appearances: 230
  • Goals: 62
  • Penalty Conversion: 100%

1. Alan Shearer

Despite missing over 10 penalties, Shearer tops the chart with 56 successful spot-kicks. His reputation as the league’s top scorer reflects his talent and nerve.

  • Appearances: 441
  • Goals: 260
  • Penalty Conversion: 84%

FAQs

  • Who is the Premier League’s greatest penalty taker? Alan Shearer leads the list as the best penalty taker in Premier League history.
  • Is Erling Haaland among the top 10 penalty takers? Yes, Haaland ranks seventh among the Premier League’s best penalty takers.
  • Who are the top three penalty takers in Premier League history? Alan Shearer, Yaya Touré, and Matt Le Tissier hold the top three spots.
  • Where does Erling Haaland rank among the best penalty takers? He stands seventh on the all-time Premier League penalty taker list.

Related News