Erling Haaland and Man City Stars Could Leave for Free After Premier League Guilty Verdict, Says Legal Expert
Manchester City's recent guilty ruling in the Premier League's financial investigation has sparked talk about whether some of their biggest stars might leave without transfer fees. According to barrister Paul Gilroy KC, players including Erling Haaland could legally terminate their contracts and exit as free agents.
Details of the Verdict and Its Impact
The club was found guilty on 114 out of 115 charges related to breaches such as fake contracts with commercial partners from 2009 to 2018. This judgment has raised questions about the loyalty and future of key players at the Etihad Stadium. While Manchester City denies wrongdoing and plans to appeal, the verdict creates a rare situation where players might claim their contracts are no longer valid.
Legal Perspective on Contract Terminations
On the "Stick to Football" podcast, Paul Gilroy KC explained how employment law might allow players to end their contracts early. He said every employment contract contains an implied term of trust and confidence between employer and employee, even if it is not explicitly written.
"If you don’t trust me or I don’t trust you, the relationship can’t continue," Gilroy said. "A player could argue that the club breached this implied term, giving them the right to tear up their contract and walk away."
Rival Clubs React to the Possibility
The discussion led to playful speculation about whether clubs like Liverpool or Arsenal might sign Haaland on a free transfer. Jamie Carragher jokingly asked if Liverpool could snap him up immediately, and Gilroy answered, "Yeah, why not?" Ian Wright teased that Haaland might want to join Arsenal because of friends there.
These comments highlight how the transfer market could be shaken if players at City successfully claim the right to leave without fees.
What’s Next for Manchester City?
Manchester City must file their appeal by Friday to contest the commission’s decision. The outcome will shape any sanctions and determine how the club and players move forward. Meanwhile, coach Enzo Maresca and the squad have to stay focused on football amid ongoing uncertainty.
- Next Match: Liverpool vs. Manchester City
- Date: 11 Oct 2026
- Time: 18:30
